Dr. Barbara Bartlik
MD - Psychiatrist

Vitamins

Supporting Mental Health Through Essential Nutrients

Targeted vitamins and nutritional support can play a key role in mood, energy, and overall mental wellbeing—especially when underlying deficiencies are addressed. 

Dr. Bartlik's Recommendations for Nutritional Supplements

The following six supplements offer a basic foundation for general health. I recommend these to nearly all of my patients. They may be taken on their own or along with the supplements in the next section for specific health concerns.

It is important to take high quality nutritional supplements that contain the ingredients that they are supposed to, and not undesirable or ineffective ingredients. I carefully select high quality nutritional supplements tailored to my patients’ individual needs. They come in tablets, capsules, powders, or liquids, that may combine multiple ingredients. They are not for sale on this website or listed by brand name, but may be obtained by making an appointment with me or with another qualified healthcare professional.

Basic Foundation:

    • Magnesium
    • Multivitamins
    • Omega-3 fatty acids
    • Probiotics
    • Vitamin C
    • Vitamin D3

Support for Mental Health Concerns

Anxiety

  • 5-HTP, CBD oil, GABA, glycine, green tea, iron, L-5-methyltetrahydrofolate, L-theanine, lavender, lithium orotate, magnesium, N-acetylcysteine (NAC), omega-3 fatty acids, passionflower extract, probiotics, SAM-e, saffron, taurine, tryptophan, valerian extract, vitamin B6 (P5P), vitamin B12 (methylcobalamin), vitamin D3, zinc.

Depression

  • 5-HTP, Asian (Panax) ginseng, CBD oil, creatine, folate, glycine, green tea, iron, L-5-methyltetrahydrofolate, lecithin, lithium orotate, magnesium, manganese, N-acetylcysteine (NAC), omega-3 fatty acids, phenylalanine, probiotics, SAM-e, saffron, St. John’s wort, trimethylglycine (TMG), tryptophan, vitamin B6 (P5P), vitamin B12 (methylcobalamin), vitamin C, vitamin D3, zinc.

Attention / Focus

  • Caffeine, magnesium threonate, methylcobalamin, phosphatidyl choline, phosphatidyl serine, pregnenolone, pterostilbene, theacrine.

Support for Sexual Health Concerns

Sexual Function in Men and Women

Alpha GTP, arginine, ashwagandha, ATP, beetroot, beta-phenylethylamine, chrysin (men), citrulline, cordyceps, DHEA, DL-phenylalanine, fenugreek, folate, holy basil, huperzine A, L-5-methyltetrahydrofolate, L-arginine, L-citrulline, maca (maca root), magnesium, methylcobalamin (vitamin B12), mucuna pruriens, N-acetylcysteine (NAC), pantothenic acid (vitamin B5), Panax ginseng, phosphatidyl serine, pycnogenol, Rhodiola rosea, SAM-e, schisandra, selenium, Tongkat Ali, Tribulus terrestris, tyrosine, vinpocetine, vitamin B6 (P5P), vitamin C, vitamin D3, xanthanol nicotinate, zinc.

Support for Methylation Concerns

Methylation

  • Undermethylated: Betaine, calcium, L-5-methyltetrahydrofolate, magnesium, methionine, riboflavin (vitamin B2), tocotrienols, vitamin B6 (P5P), vitamin B12 (methylcobalamin), vitamin C, zinc.
  • Overmethylated: Folinic acid or folic acid, hydroxocobalamin (vitamin B12), manganese, niacin (vitamin B3), vitamin B6 (P5P), vitamin C, zinc.

Support for Stress / Cortisol Concerns

Estrogen dominance in women and excess estrogen in men (In women, heavy or painful periods, premenstrual symptoms, hot flashes, peri-menopausal symptoms, insomnia, mood swings; In men, gynecomastia)

  • 3,3’ -diindomethane (DIM), black pepper extract, turmeric extract, hops, plant lignans, alpha lipoic acid, milk thistle, methoselenocysteine, N-acetylcysteine, glucoraphanin, plant nutrients, green tea catechins, bioflavonoids, resveratrol, quercetin, pterostilbene, chasteberry, black cohash, calcium-D-glucarate, folate, methylcobalamin, vitamin B6, calcium, magnesium, isoflavones, choline, lecithin, omega 3 fatty acids, flaxseed

Low or dysregulated cortisol

  • Rhodiola rosea, cordyceps, panax ginseng, vitamin B6, pantothenic acid, para-aminobenzoic acid (PABA), vitamin C, Ashwaganda, holy basil, eleuthero extract, schisandra, licorice, bovine adrenal gland.

High cortisol

  • Phosphatidylserine, magnolia officinalis, phellodendron amurense bark extract, ashwaganda,  L-theanine, banaba leaf.

Support for Other Health Concerns

Insomnia/ sleep

  • Melatonin, Magnesium, Glycine, L-theanine, Valerian root, Lavender, Passionflower, Lemon balm, Tryptophan, Phosphatidylserine, CBD oil, Catnip tea

Constipation

  • Konjac fiber, Magnesium (citrate, sulfate, or oxide), Probiotics, Psyllium, Dietary fiber, Probiotics, Slippery elm,  Vitamin C, Buffered ascorbate powder, Digestive enzymes (if indicated)

Antioxidants

  • Vitamin C, Vitamin E, Vitamin A, Citrus bioflavonoid complex, Turmeric extract (curcumin), N-acetyl L-cysteine, Glutathione, S-acetyl L-glutathione, Delta-tocotrienols

Nutritional supplements contained in over-the-counter products to support mental, sexual, and general health concerns

Listed in order of importance – Click on title to view all supplements 

RankSupplementWhy It Works
1MagnesiumHelps regulate the nervous system and stress response; deficiency is linked with anxiety.
2L-theaninePromotes relaxation without sedation by increasing alpha brain waves.
3Omega-3 fatty acidsReduce neuroinflammation and support healthy brain function.
4SaffronSeveral clinical trials show benefits for anxiety and mood.
5LavenderOral lavender oil has good evidence for generalized anxiety.
6Vitamin D3Correcting the deficiency may improve anxiety symptoms.
7N-acetylcysteine (NAC)Modulates glutamate and oxidative stress; it may reduce anxiety and compulsive symptoms.
8ProbioticsGut-brain axis effects may improve stress resilience and anxiety.
9GlycineMay promote calmness and improve sleep quality.
10TaurineSupports GABA signaling and has calming effects.
11Passionflower extractMild anxiolytic effects have been demonstrated in several studies.
12Valerian extractPrimarily helps anxiety associated with insomnia.
13Vitamin B6 (P5P)Required for GABA and serotonin synthesis.
14Vitamin B12 (methylcobalamin)Correcting the deficiency may improve mood and anxiety.
15L-5-methyltetrahydrofolate (5-MTHF)Supports neurotransmitter synthesis, especially if folate-deficient.
16ZincLow zinc has been associated with anxiety disorders.
17IronHelpful only if a deficiency is present.
18SAM-eBetter evidence for depression than anxiety, but it may improve mood.
19TryptophanSerotonin precursor that may reduce anxiety in some individuals.
205-HTPIncreases serotonin production; evidence is mixed.
21Green teaContains L-theanine and polyphenols, which may help reduce stress.
22GABALimited evidence that oral GABA crosses the blood-brain barrier.
23CBD oilPromising, but evidence is still emerging.
24Lithium orotateVery limited clinical evidence compared with prescription lithium.
RankSupplementWhy It Works
1Omega-3 fatty acidsStrong evidence, especially EPA-rich formulas, for improving depressive symptoms.
2SAM-eWell-studied natural antidepressant that increases neurotransmitter synthesis.
3L-5-methyltetrahydrofolate (5-MTHF)An effective adjunct, particularly in people with MTHFR variants or low folate.
4SaffronMultiple studies show effectiveness comparable to antidepressants for mild-to-moderate depression.
5St. John’s wortStrong evidence for mild-to-moderate depression (significant drug interactions).
6Vitamin D3Correcting the deficiency may improve depressive symptoms.
7MagnesiumSupports neurotransmitter regulation and stress response.
8CreatineImproves brain energy metabolism and has promising evidence, particularly in women.
9N-acetylcysteine (NAC)Reduces oxidative stress and modulates glutamate.
10ProbioticsGut microbiome modulation may improve mood.
11Vitamin B12 (methylcobalamin)Important when a deficiency contributes to depression.
12Vitamin B6 (P5P)Supports serotonin and dopamine production.
13ZincFrequently low in depression; supplementation may improve outcomes.
14Panax ginsengMay improve energy, fatigue, and mood.
15TryptophanSerotonin precursor with moderate evidence.
165-HTPSerotonin precursor; evidence is mixed.
17FolateHelps correct folate deficiency affecting mood.
18PhenylalanineDopamine and norepinephrine precursor; limited evidence.
19Vitamin CAntioxidant deficiency can contribute to fatigue and low mood. Increases iron absorption.
20IronHelpful if iron deficiency is present.
21TMG (Trimethylglycine)Supports methylation and homocysteine metabolism.
22Green teaPolyphenols and L-theanine may provide mild mood benefits.
23GlycineMay improve sleep and overall well-being.
24LecithinLimited evidence for depression. Supports brain health.
25Lithium orotateLimited evidence compared with prescription lithium. Lower depression and suicide rates in lithium-rich drinking water areas.
RankSupplementWhy It Works
1CaffeineStrong evidence for improving alertness, vigilance, reaction time, and sustained attention.
2L-theanineEnhances attention and focus, especially when combined with caffeine, while reducing jitteriness.
3Citicoline (CDP-choline)Increases acetylcholine and phospholipid synthesis, improving attention, memory, and executive function.
4Omega-3 fatty acids (especially DHA)Supports neuronal membrane function and improves cognition, particularly in people with low intake.
5Bacopa monnieriStudies show improvements in attention, memory, and information processing after 8–12 weeks.
6CreatineImproves brain energy metabolism, mental performance, and working memory, especially during fatigue.
7Rhodiola roseaReduces mental fatigue and improves concentration under stress.
8PhosphatidylserineSupports neuronal membranes and improves attention, executive function, and memory. Reduces cortisol.
9Panax ginsengImproves mental performance, working memory, and cognitive speed.
10Magnesium L-threonateMay improve memory and cognitive performance.
11Ginkgo bilobaMay improve attention, processing speed, and cerebral blood flow, particularly in older adults.
12L-TyrosineDopamine precursor that improves focus during stress, sleep deprivation, and demanding tasks.
13PycnogenolMay improve attention and reduce hyperactivity, particularly in ADHD.
14SaffronMay benefit attention and ADHD symptoms.
15Acetyl-L-carnitine (ALCAR)Supports mitochondrial energy production and cognitive function.
RankSupplementWhy It Works
1Omega-3 fatty acids (especially DHA)Essential for neuronal membranes and may slow cognitive decline, particularly in those with low dietary intake.
2Citicoline (CDP-choline)Increases acetylcholine; supports neuronal membrane repair, improving memory and executive function.
3Ginkgo bilobaBest studied botanical for mild cognitive impairment; may improve memory, attention, and cerebral blood flow.
4PhosphatidylserineSupports neuronal membrane integrity; improves memory and cognitive performance.
5Bacopa monnieriImproves memory, learning, and information processing.
6Magnesium L-threonateMay improve memory and synaptic function.
7Huperzine AInhibits acetylcholinesterase, increasing acetylcholine to support memory and learning.
8Curcumin (Turmeric extract)Reduces neuroinflammation and oxidative stress associated with cognitive decline.
9Acetyl-L-carnitineSupports mitochondrial function and may improve memory and mental energy.
10Vitamin B12 (Methylcobalamin)Corrects B12 deficiency that can cause cognitive impairment.
11Vitamin D3Low levels are associated with cognitive decline; correcting D3 deficiency may improve function.
12N-acetylcysteine (NAC)Increases glutathione, reducing oxidative stress and supporting neuronal health.
13CreatineImproves brain energy metabolism, particularly during aging and mental fatigue.
14Lion’s Mane mushroomMay stimulate nerve growth factor and improve cognition in mild cognitive impairment.
15Alpha-GPCCholine donor that supports acetylcholine production and memory.
16Coenzyme Q10Supports mitochondrial energy production and neuronal function.
17PycnogenolAn antioxidant that may improve memory and attention through vascular effects.
18ResveratrolMay improve cerebral blood flow and reduce neuroinflammation.
19Rhodiola roseaReduces mental fatigue and may improve cognitive performance under stress.
20PhosphatidylcholineProvides choline for acetylcholine synthesis and supports neuronal membranes.
21Vitamin EAn antioxidant that may slow the decline in some individuals with Alzheimer’s disease.
22SaffronMay benefit mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease.
23L-theaninePromotes relaxed attention and may improve cognitive performance.
24ZincSupports neuronal signaling; supplementation is beneficial primarily in deficiency.
25PterostilbeneAntioxidant with potential neuroprotective effects; limited evidence.
Rank Supplement Why It Works
1 L-arginine Increases nitric oxide production, improves blood flow and sexual arousal; best evidence for erectile dysfunction.
2 Panax ginseng Well-studied for improving erectile function, libido, energy, and sexual satisfaction.
3 Pycnogenol Enhances nitric oxide production; particularly effective when combined with L-arginine.
4 L-citrulline Raises arginine levels more effectively than oral arginine and improves erectile function.
5 Maca Multiple trials support improvements in libido in both men and women.
6 Ashwagandha May improve libido, sexual satisfaction, testosterone, and stress-related sexual dysfunction.
7 Tongkat Ali Good evidence for improving libido, erectile function, testosterone, and fertility in men.
8 Fenugreek Clinical studies show improvements in libido and sexual desire in both sexes.
9 DHEA Can improve libido in women with adrenal insufficiency or postmenopausal women and in selected men with a deficiency.
10 Beetroot Provides dietary nitrates that increase nitric oxide and improve circulation.
11 Rhodiola rosea Reduces fatigue and stress that contribute to sexual dysfunction.
12 SAM-e May improve mood-related sexual dysfunction and help offset antidepressant-induced dysfunction.
13 Magnesium Supports hormone production, vascular health, and nerve function.
14 Vitamin D3 Deficiency is associated with low testosterone and sexual dysfunction.
15 Zinc Essential for testosterone production, fertility, and sexual function.
16 Methylcobalamin (Vitamin B12) Supports nerve health and energy, especially if deficient.
17 L-5-methyltetrahydrofolate (5-MTHF) Supports methylation and neurotransmitter production that influence libido.
18 N-acetylcysteine (NAC) May improve oxidative stress and fertility parameters.
19 Cordyceps Traditional aphrodisiac with emerging evidence for its effects on energy and sexual function.
20 Mucuna pruriens Increases dopamine activity and may improve libido and fertility.
21 Tribulus terrestris Better evidence for increasing libido than testosterone; benefits appear greater in women.
22 Selenium Important for sperm production and antioxidant protection.
23 Vitamin B6 (P5P) Supports neurotransmitter and hormone synthesis.
24 Tyrosine A dopamine precursor that may improve motivation and desire.
25 DL-Phenylalanine Supports dopamine and norepinephrine synthesis.
26 Vitamin C Supports nitric oxide production and reduces oxidative stress. Increases iron absorption.
27 Pantothenic acid (Vitamin B5) Supports adrenal hormone production.
28 Schisandra An adaptogen that may improve stamina and reduce fatigue.
29 Phosphatidylserine May reduce stress and cortisol, indirectly benefiting sexual function.
30 Chrysin (men) Limited evidence that it increases testosterone or improves sexual function in humans.
Rank Supplement Why It Works
1 L-5-methyltetrahydrofolate (5-MTHF) Active folate that directly supports methylation and neurotransmitter synthesis.
2 Vitamin B12 (methylcobalamin) Essential cofactor for methionine synthase and methylation.
3 Vitamin B6 (P5P) Supports methylation and neurotransmitter production.
4 Riboflavin (Vitamin B2) Important cofactor for MTHFR, especially in people with MTHFR variants.
5 Betaine (TMG) Donates methyl groups, lowering homocysteine levels.
6 Methionine Essential amino acid and precursor of SAM-e, the body’s universal methyl donor.
7 Magnesium Required for hundreds of enzymatic reactions, including methylation pathways.
8 Zinc Supports enzymes involved in DNA synthesis and methylation.
9 Vitamin C Supports enzyme function and protects against oxidative stress.
Rank Supplement Why It Works
1 Niacin (Vitamin B3) Uses methyl groups during metabolism and may reduce excess methylation.
2 Hydroxocobalamin (Vitamin B12) Provides vitamin B12 without adding methyl groups, making it preferable to methylcobalamin for patients with overmethylated status.
3 Folinic acid Supports folate metabolism without supplying methyl groups directly.
4 Vitamin B6 (P5P) Supports balanced neurotransmitter synthesis and methylation pathways.
5 Vitamin C An antioxidant that may reduce oxidative stress associated with methylation imbalances.
6 Zinc Supports numerous methylation-related enzymes but has no specific role in reducing methylation.
Rank Supplement Why It Works
1 3,3′-Diindolylmethane (DIM) Promotes healthier estrogen metabolism by shifting estrogen toward less potent metabolites.
2 Calcium D-glucarate Enhances estrogen elimination by reducing enterohepatic recycling.
3 Flaxseed Rich in lignans that modulate estrogen activity and improve hormone balance.
4 Glucoraphanin (broccoli sprout extract) Increases sulforaphane production, supporting liver detoxification and estrogen metabolism.
5 Milk thistle Supports liver function, which is essential for hormone metabolism.
6 N-acetylcysteine (NAC) Raises glutathione levels, improving detoxification and reducing oxidative stress.
7 Omega-3 fatty acids Reduce inflammation and improve cell membrane sensitivity to hormones.
8 Chasteberry (Vitex) Good evidence for PMS and cyclic breast pain through effects on prolactin.
9 Green tea Antioxidant effects may influence estrogen metabolism.
10 Resveratrol Mild phytoestrogen with antioxidant and anti-inflammatory effects.
11 Quercetin An anti-inflammatory flavonoid that may influence estrogen signaling.
12 Turmeric (curcumin) Reduces inflammation and may modulate estrogen-related pathways.
13 Black cohosh Helps menopausal symptoms but does not significantly alter estrogen levels.
14 Magnesium Supports hormone balance and may reduce PMS symptoms.
15 Vitamin B6 (P5P) Supports estrogen metabolism and neurotransmitter synthesis.
16 Folate Supports methylation needed for estrogen metabolism.
17 Methylcobalamin (Vitamin B12) Works with folate in methylation pathways.
18 Choline Supports liver function and methylation.
19 Plant lignans Weak phytoestrogens that may help balance estrogen activity.
20 Isoflavones May reduce menopausal symptoms by weakly binding estrogen receptors.
21 Alpha-lipoic acid An antioxidant that supports liver health.
22 Bioflavonoids Antioxidants with modest support for vascular and hormonal health.
23 Pterostilbene Similar to resveratrol, with limited evidence.
24 Calcium Helpful for PMS symptoms but not for estrogen metabolism directly.
Rank Supplement Why It Works
1 Rhodiola rosea Best evidence for reducing fatigue and improving resilience to stress.
2 Panax ginseng Improves energy, stamina, sexuality, and stress adaptation.
3 Ashwagandha Reduces cortisol levels and improves stress tolerance and sex hormone levels. Calming.
4 Cordyceps Supports energy production and physical endurance.
5 Vitamin C Highly concentrated in the adrenal glands and supports cortisol synthesis.
6 Pantothenic acid (Vitamin B5) Essential for adrenal hormone production.
7 Eleuthero extract An adaptogen that improves resistance to stress and fatigue.
8 Schisandra An adaptogen that supports endurance and stress resilience.
9 Licorice Slows cortisol breakdown, prolonging cortisol activity (use cautiously due to hypertension).
10 Vitamin B6 (P5P) Supports adrenal hormone and neurotransmitter synthesis.
11 Holy basil An adaptogen that helps regulate the stress response.
Rank Supplement Why It Works
1 Phosphatidylserine Reduces excessive cortisol release after physical or psychological stress.
2 Ashwagandha Consistently lowers cortisol and improves anxiety and stress symptoms.
3 L-theanine Promotes relaxation and reduces stress without causing drowsiness.
4 Magnolia officinalis May reduce anxiety and cortisol.
5 Banaba leaf Primarily supports blood sugar regulation; limited evidence for lowering cortisol.
Support for other health concerns
RankSupplementWhy It Works
1MelatoninImproves sleep onset, jet lag, and circadian rhythm disorders.
2MagnesiumPromotes relaxation and improves sleep quality, especially if deficient.
3L-theanineIncreases relaxation without sedation and improves sleep quality.
4GlycineImproves sleep quality and lowers core body temperature before sleep.
5Valerian rootModest evidence for improving sleep quality and reducing sleep latency.
6LavenderOral lavender and aromatherapy improve sleep and anxiety.
7PassionflowerMild sedative effects that may improve sleep quality.
8Lemon balmA calming herb that may improve insomnia and anxiety.
9PhosphatidylserineMay improve sleep by lowering elevated nighttime cortisol.
10TryptophanSerotonin and melatonin precursors that may improve sleep onset.
11CBD oilEvidence is mixed; it may improve sleep in some individuals, especially when anxiety contributes.
RankSupplementWhy It Works
1PsylliumStrongest evidence among fiber supplements for improving stool frequency and consistency.
2Magnesium (especially citrate)Draws water into the bowel and softens stools.
3Dietary fiberIncreases stool bulk and promotes regular bowel movements.
4ProbioticsMay improve gut microbiota and increase stool frequency in chronic constipation.
5Konjac fiber (glucomannan)Soluble fiber that improves stool bulk and bowel regularity.
6Vitamin CHigher doses have an osmotic effect that can soften stools.
7Buffered ascorbate powderA gentle form of vitamin C that can promote bowel movements at higher doses.
8Slippery elmMucilage may soothe the gastrointestinal tract and ease stool passage.
9Digestive enzymesHelpful only when constipation is related to digestive insufficiency rather than slow transit.
Rank Supplement Why It Works
1 Vitamin C A major water-soluble antioxidant that regenerates other antioxidants and supports immune function.
2 N-acetyl L-cysteine (NAC) Increases glutathione production, the body’s primary intracellular antioxidant.
3 Turmeric extract (Curcumin) Potent antioxidant and anti-inflammatory compound.
4 Vitamin E A major fat-soluble antioxidant that protects cell membranes from oxidative damage.
5 Glutathione The body’s master antioxidant; supports detoxification and cellular defense.
6 S-acetyl L-glutathione More stable, orally absorbable form of glutathione.
7 Delta-tocotrienols Members of the vitamin E family have potent antioxidant and cardiovascular effects.
8 Citrus bioflavonoid complex Enhances vitamin C activity and reduces oxidative stress.
9 Vitamin A Supports immune function and antioxidant defense, but should not be supplemented excessively due to the risk of toxicity.